How Do Trade Secrets Compare to Patents?
A discussion of trade secret protection often includes a comparison to patent protection.
Although trade secrets are potentially unlimited in duration, what can be overlooked is that public use of a trade secret can forever bar the owners' right to a patent internationally, and in the United States can bar the owner's right to a patent if a patent application is not submitted within one year of the disclosure. Trade secrets also do not protect against a competitor independently discovering or reverse engineering the trade secret, where patent protection may afford better protection. So, the best way to determine which form of protection is better for protecting your technology is to compare the limitations of both strategies.
Patents and Trade Secrets Compared
| Patent | Trade secret | |
|---|---|---|
| How long it lasts | 20 years from the nonprovisional filing, or up to 21 years from a provisional filed first, if maintenance fees are paid | As long as the information stays secret and reasonable measures protect it |
| What becomes public | The application, generally 18 months after filing | Nothing |
| Independent discovery or reverse engineering by a competitor | Generally still infringement; copying is not required | Lawful; not misappropriation |
| Best suited to | What can be inspected once the product is sold, such as hardware | What cannot be seen from the product, such as manufacturing processes and test methods |
When Is a Trade Secret Better?
Is your technical information available for protection as a trade secret? If so, what are the circumstances surrounding the protected information that could weaken that protection? Compare the protections and remedies available under trade secret protection to that under patent protection before making a firm decision as to which strategy makes the best sense for you.
Related topics: know-how.
