What Is Know-How, and Is It Intellectual Property?

What Is Know-How, and Is It Intellectual Property?

"Know how" is practical knowledge that is difficult or impossible to reduce in tangible form, such as by writing or verbal communication. Think of a trade secret as a special recipe for bread (which can be written down and stored), but know-how as a method of kneading the bread with skill which can only be shown in person. In our attorneys' personal experiences with some of the largest pharmaceutical manufacturers, the scale-up of small quantities of Active Pharmaceutical Ingredients ("APIs") is considered know-how, and can be invaluable.

At a Glance

  • Definition: Practical knowledge that is difficult or impossible to reduce in tangible form
  • Compared with a trade secret: A trade secret is the recipe for bread; know-how is kneading it with skill
  • In contracts: Often defined defensively to capture everything outside "traditional" IP
  • Value: Can have substantial economic value and can be leveraged using an offensive IP strategy

Trade Secret or Know-How?

Trade secretKnow-how
In a bakeryThe special recipe for the breadThe skill of kneading the dough
How it is heldCan be written down and storedDifficult or impossible to reduce to tangible form
How it is passed onBy disclosing the recordBy showing it in person: demonstrating the technique and training a collaborator
In pharmaceutical manufacturing, the scale-up of small quantities of an active pharmaceutical ingredient is considered know-how.

How Is Know-How Treated in Contracts?

Many businesses lump intellectual property (IP) that is not a patent, trademark or copyright into one category they deem to be "know how." In fact, one often sees the term "know how" defined defensively in contracts to attempt to capture everything that cannot be nailed down by "traditional" IP. Such terms look like:

"Know How" shall mean: processes, methods, compositions, formulae, procedures, protocols, software developments and improvements, techniques, results of experimentation and testing, information and data, which are not generally known, (i) embodying or produced through use of XYZ Patent Rights and associated know-how, or (ii) embodying or produced through inventions conceived, discovered or reduced to practice, whether alone or with others, by XYZ employees or with XYZ facilities or equipment, in the course of any program under this agreement, or (iii) otherwise regarding the Field, in which XYZ has an ownership or other interest during the term of this Agreement; all to the extent and only to the extent that XYZ has the right to grant licenses or other rights thereunder.

How Can Know-How Be Used Offensively?

However, this type of intangible asset can have substantial economic value and can be leveraged using an offensive IP strategy. Know how can include a demonstration of technique and how a product is manufactured, assembled or processed. It can also be confidential information not found in patents claiming a certain product or process. Although a valid patent requires that the "best mode" of making and using the product or process claimed in a patent application be included at the time of filing, new or improved modes can be developed later. The ability to train a collaborator in the subtleties of making a product can be a very valuable asset to leverage as part of a comprehensive IP strategy.

Related topics: licensing.

Questions about know-how? Call +1 (858) 869-1250 or schedule a consultation.